Pros and Cons of Personality Testing

Pros and Cons of Personality Testing

Source: Accounting Office Management & Administration Report

Will personality tests help identify candidates who’ll be compatible with your culture and who may become leaders? Consider:

Pro:

  • Such tests tend to be better than management at making predictions.

Cons:

  • Tests may be unreliable.
  • Tests may discriminate on sex or religion.
  • Tests are often used incorrectly—as tests that must be passed.
  • Tests may violate the Americans with Disabilities Act.

Tips:

  • To avoid violating disabilities laws, don’t use any questions on addiction or psychological problems
  • Don’t rely solely on the test. Use other measures, including skills tests and interviews.
  • Provide test results to candidates and allow them to ask questions.

Popular tests:

  • Meyers-Briggs
  • California Personality Inventory
  • Keirsey Temperament Sorter

From Accounting Office Management & Administration Report, December 2005, p. 9. For subscription information contact Institute of Management & Administration, Inc., 3 Park Avenue, 30th Floor, New York, NY 10016-5902. One-year subscription $329. 212-244-0360, [email protected].