Vol. 6 No. 4, April 2014

The Leadership Forum is a panel of the most prominent thought leaders in the profession. Each month we ask them to respond to a question dealing with CPA firm management and leadership.

This month's question is:

The average tenure of CPA firm marketing directors and coordinators is an awful 19 months? Why is this and what can these people do (short of silly unattainable feats like bringing in tons of business) to stay many years instead of a handful of months?

 


Consultants and Other Prominent Observers

August Aquila  AQUILA Global Advisors, LLC www.aquilaadvisors.com
[email protected]
What a great question. There are many things that firm marketing directors can do to ensure a longer tenure with their firm and there are many things firms need to do to help the marketing director succeed. The firm needs to identify what it wants the marketing director to do. If it is marketing, then the marketing director will be responsible for everything the firm does to get and keep clients (communications, training, proposals, developing firm and individual marketing plans, creating a marketing culture in the firm, etc.). Quite a list of things to do! Depending on the life cycle of the firm, these different activities will vary. The marketing director also needs to report directly to the managing partner and should be a key part of the leadership team. Effective marketing will only take place in your firm if you and your partners develop a marketing culture and attitude. Basically this means placing the clients at the center of all marketing activities. Once the firm decides what it wants and develops a position description then it can hire the right person for the position.

Marketing directors needs to spend time with the managing partner and other partners. They need to understand the firm's culture, how partners are compensated, they need to get partner support and win over some of the skeptics. Marketing is a managerial function, it needs to lead within a firm. Added to the difficulty of the position today, many firms are hiring business development professionals as well as marketing professionals. Often the two are different breeds.


Ron Baker  VeraSage Institute www.verasage.com
[email protected]
I believe it's because firm leaders conflate marketing and selling. Management genius Peter Drucker preached, "The aim of marketing is to make selling superfluous." In other words, the goal of marketing is to make a product, service, or company so relevant and compelling that it literally sells itself. If your firm would spend more time and energy developing and marketing a relevant, differentiated service, you could spend a lot less time and energy trying to sell it.

If you think this is hyperbole, consider captivating products like the iPhone. Can you imagine ever seeing an iPhone salesman? Instead, zealous customers are lined up in front of Apple stores for hours. Too many firms expect growth for the sake of the growth from their CMOs. Well, growth for the sake of growth is the ideology of the cancer cell, not a sustainable, long-term profitable business. The right customers, at the right price, is what matters. Again, look at Apple. They've never cared about market share, yet the have the majority of profits in almost every market they enter (especially with the iPhone and iPad).

If firms stopped expecting their marketers to sell and instead actually engage in marketing, CMOs would be far more effective in their positions.


Gary Boomer  Boomer Consulting, Inc. www.boomer.com
[email protected]
The problem starts with expectations and lack of understanding on the part of most partners with regard to the job description. A marketing director's primary responsibility is to get opportunities (at bat's) while sales is closing deals (hits). The unique abilities of a marketing director and a business developer are generally significantly different. The other challenge is working for multiple partners who provide little guidance and often have different visions. Start with a job description the partners have agreed upon, operate with a 90 day game plan and conduct quarterly reviews. Set realistic goals. Too many firms try to start with an inexperienced marketing talent at entry level prices and are then quickly dissatisfied. Marketing personnel can quickly become frustrated and often find better employment with a couple of year's experience. Don't be afraid to use professionals in the hiring process and tools such as the Kolbe Index to insure a right fit. A marketing professional can be an important addition to your team. There is a good chance the problem is with the firm and not with the marketing professional when the average tenure is 19 months!

Jean Marie Caragher   Capstone Marketing www.capstonemarketing.com
[email protected]
Not knowing the source of this statistic I am not sure that it is accurate. My sense is that the average tenure of CPA firm marketing directors is closer to four years. There are many marketers who have achieved the level of partner, principal, or chief marketing officer. With that said there are several things marketers can do to lengthen their time with their firms.

Marketers must understand the accounting profession and their firms. Read books. Attend conferences. Build your network. Talk to your partners. Understand the services your firm provides, the industry specialties, how your firm makes money.

Marketers must think strategically. When creating the firm's marketing plan the marketer must make a business case for each program or campaign. The marketing plan should support the firm's vision and goals. Think like an owner/partner. Show results.

Marketers must have strong communication skills. Communicate early and often about how you spend your time and the status of marketing programs. CPA firm marketers are busy people. Your partners shouldn't be wondering about what you are doing. Make sure that you are working on the high priority items. Manage your time.

Marketers must focus on their strengths. Know what you do well and what you need help with. Make the business case for additional marketing team members or outsourcing services.

There are also things that partners can do, including:

  • Not hiring a marketer until they are committed to making them successful.
  • Defining the role and expectations of their marketer before hiring anyone.
  • Treating their marketer with respect and trusting the ideas they bring to the table.

William Carlino  Transition Advisors www.transitionadvisors.com
[email protected]
It's incumbent upon the CPA firm employers to get them involved in various aspects of the firm, as opposed to simply attracting new client business. That includes getting their input in growth strategies, allowing them to raise the profile of the firm for placement in print and other media positioning them as experts on accounting-related stories and ultimately, creating a path to equity in the firm as a principal or partner.

Angie Grissom   The Rainmaker Companies www.therainmakercompanies.com
[email protected]
Accounting firm leaders and marketing professionals are very different. They bring different skill sets to the firm and sometimes have a difficult time communicating with one another. Creative types are hired because firm leaders know they do not personally possess these skills that are needed in the firm and hope to bring in others that will supplement this. The problem is that once these marketing professionals are brought in, they have a difficult time proving their value because they are so different from CPAs. The key is to set realistic expectations for performance, schedule regular reviews for the marketing professionals and establish regular meetings where the marketing professionals are involved in overall firm strategy sessions and are able to contribute to the thinking in these sessions. Accounting professionals should be open to new ideas but marketing professionals should be aware that the more they can demonstrate their value in supporting firm growth-the better off they are. A tremendous amount of value exists in having people with varying skill sets as part of the team. I wish the average tenure was a lot longer. It can be with the right combination of expectations and performance.

Rita Keller  Keller Advisors, LLC www.ritakeller.com
[email protected]
I encounter many marketing directors, HR Directors and even a few firm administrators working inside CPA firms who really don't understand the business of public accounting.

I urge people in professional support roles for CPA firms to be bold in pressuring the partners to help them learn the business. Much of the training about the services the firm provides can be taught internally. However, most firm leaders just want them to "do marketing stuff" and the new hires respond by just focusing on a narrow path because they "aim to please".

A career development plan for a CPA firm marketer is just as important as a career development plan for a new accounting college graduate. Firm leaders need to take on the role of educating these people - new hires, without previous CPA firm experience, don't know what they don't know. Part of the plan is facilitating their exposure to others in the profession. Have them join the Association for Accounting Marketing or The Association for Accounting Administration. Hire a coach or advisor to help them quickly get up to speed. Send them to the national conferences of AAM or AAA or ones sponsored by the AICPA.

Bottom-line - firms must be generous with CPE dollars for these professional support positions. But that's not all, CPA leaders need to budget time to mentor and train these support professionals.


Ric Payne Principa www.principa.net   
[email protected]  
The sad answer is they don't get results so they are either fired or leave out of frustration. Maybe a better question is why don't they get results? I think there are two answers. First, some of these people have no idea about professional services marketing. Second, the ones who do know what they're doing don't get real support from senior leaders and are left to figure out what marketing strategy the firm needs to implement. The lack of a clear marketing objective that's aligned with the firm's vision and supported with measurable benchmarks on a reasonable time frame is essential.

Marc Rosenberg The Rosenberg Associates www.rosenbergassoc.com   
[email protected]  
The rapid turnover among CPA firm marketing directors occurs for these reasons, among others:
  • Firms hire them for the wrong reasons. Best example: Bringing in business. That's not what they do.
  • Partners get frustrated at their own failure to grow the firm, so they decide one day to hire a marketing director to see if that works. When they see that doesn't work, they fire the person.
  • Firms under-hire. To save a buck, they hire a young (usually female), relatively inexperienced person from another field. But the person usually lacks the assertiveness to stand up to the partners.

Here are some things marketing directors can do to increase their tenure:

  1. Manage expectations. Most marketing personnel are not hired to sell. Yet, it's common for partners to expect this. Make sure the partners are educated on this.
  2. Need to report to a MP, not a committee or an COO.
  3. Be part of the visioning process; be a strategist, not just a tactician.
  4. Deliver what you say you're going to deliver. Partners like to see follow-through and tangible end-results.
  5. Build trust through little successes; Focus on a few things and do them really well.
  6. Show you're a team player; step up and take on other duties.

Joseph Tarasco Accountants Advisory Group www.accountantsadvisory.com 
[email protected]  
Quite often, the problem is not the failure of the marketing personnel, but rather a failure of the process as to when marketing ends and sales begins. Selling is a contact sport that takes numerous communications and a significant amount of touches with prospects. Marketing programs and professionals should support the selling process that is ultimately the responsibility of the partners.

It's easy to blame the marketing directors and their staff when revenue growth is slow but typically they are not the problem. Here are some suggestions that will assist your firm in getting a greater return on your marketing investment:
  • Provide professional sales training to your partners and managers on the entire sales cycle. Most accountants have never received formal sales training and don't practice proper selling techniques. Professional sales training will also motivate your partners and staff to get out the office and spend more time with prospects and referral sources. It will also reduce the fear and anxiety that accompanies selling by non-professional sales people. The potential for failure prevents many accountants from devoting the time and effort it takes to build relationships that can lead to a new client. Success at sales depends on knowing and accepting how long it takes to succeed and the number of failures you will have along the way.
  • Each partner and manager should have sales goals and objectives that are realistic and measurable for which they will be held accountable. It's essential that sales activities be monitored and results accessed periodically internally and possibly by a sales coach.
  • Closing sales normally requires building and maintaining relationships over a long period of time. It means periodically and continuously following up with "qualified" prospects and referral sources. This is where most accountants fail at selling by not maintaining the required follow-ups and contacts that are crucial to the selling process. Prospects should be evaluated periodically to determine if there is a realistic basis of closing them.
Don't blame the marketing department for lacks of new business--make more of an investment of time in selling and you will see a greater return on your marketing investment by more of your partners.

Jennifer Wilson ConvergenceCoaching LLC www.convergencecoaching.com
[email protected]
  1. Act like a consultant and avoid "attachment"
  2. Recognize that they speak a foreign language and they need to translate their ideas into CPA-speak
  3. Pick their battles
  4. Offer strategic advice, don't focus on tactical activities or get relegated to administrative tasks
  5. Focus on niche specialties and growth
  6. Work with those that WANT TO market, don't bang your head against the wall of those resisting -- they will come along when you prove success with others